Will politicians ever learn?
One of the hot topics in Irish politics at the moment centres around remuneration of our elected representatives. It was sparked off by revelations that Beverley Flynn, a Mayo TD (like an MP in England), is still receiving money that, morally, she probably shouldn’t be receiving.
If a person is elected to our national parliament as an independent candidate, i.e. not affiliated to any particular political party, it seems that they can claim and extra €41k a year on top of the €100k+ salary and expenses (which can, for TDs in more remote constituencies – like Mayo I assume, amount to a further €100k or so). This extra money is supposed to compensate for the fact that they are not backed by a ‘party machine’ and hence incur extra expenses.
So a TD could receive as much as €250k per year – that’s a quarter of a million euros of taxpayers money. Now hold on, I musn’t get side tracked here, the point of this post is not about the ridiculously large salaries these people are paid – even more if you get to be a minister of course – and the absurdly generous pension arrangements. No, this is about that ‘independent’s bonus’.
Let’s just throw in a bit of abbreviated background here, regarding Ms. Flynn. She used to work in a bank. According to a report on RTÉ, the state broadcaster, in the course of her work at the bank she would encourage people to evade tax. That’s evade, not avoid. It’s illegal. Well, she denied it of course and sued RTÉ for libel. She lost. Costs were awarded against her, to the tune of €2.4 million, she was thrown out of Fianna Fáil, her party, and became an independent. She was still an independent when she was re-elected in 2007 and so gets the little bonus. However, in 2008 she was allowed to rejoin the Fianna Fáil party because by then she had settled with RTÉ (by paying half the money she owed) but she continued to claim her independent’s bonus, which she’s entitled to do until the next election, apparently.
She reckons there’s nothing wrong with this and anyway the money is used for the benefit of her constituents.
As you can imagine, this has caused a bit of a stink. With the global financial crisis, the banks losing all our money, the economy in recession, businesses closing down, people losing their jobs and the government building up a debt of biblical proportions, you can see why some people might have a problem with Ms. Flynn claiming a bonus to which, morally at least, she is clearly not entitled. It’s OK though, the Taoiseach (prime minister, leader of the goverment) has had a word with her and she’s decided not to continue claiming the money after all. And she’s very upset at all the horrid things that people have been saying about her in recent days.
For the sake of fairness, I should point out that she is not the only TD accused of this sort of behaviour, so that’s all right then.
When will politicians learn? Will they ever learn? Or do they, if fact, know exactly what they are doing and just hope they can get away with it for long enough to feather the nest with exquisite Hungarian goose down? After all, corruption, fraud and generally dodgy behavior is hardly unknown in the world of politics. Our previous Taoiseach, the great Bertie Ahern, resigned because the questions about where he got his money were becoming a bit difficult to answer. [Interestingly, these questions were posed by a 'Tribunal of Inquiry' set up by the Bert to look into corruption in public life. Talk about 'hoisted by his own petard'.] The late Charles Haughey, another former Taoiseach, was really quite bent. Every country has similar exemplars. It would be very easy to wonder if there are any honest politicians, or is that an oxymoron?
Perhaps the real question is why, oh why, oh why, do we keep voting for these individuals? Maybe it’s because there isn’t any real choice.
